Close ILTakeCare Suggestion
IL TakeCare app – For all your insurance & wellness needs

Policy purchase, claims, renewal & more

 

Comprehensive vs bumper-to-bumper car insurance

Detailed comparison of comprehensive and bumper-to-bumper car insurance including coverage benefits limitations and selection criteria for vehicle protection.

  • 24 Feb 2025
  • 4 min read
  • 491 views

We pool so much of our savings to buy our dream car. When we buy it, it is legally necessary to get vehicle insurance for the car. This is necessary to safeguard us against any financial liabilities arising out of damage or loss of the vehicle. When buying car insurance, it is necessary to understand certain terms related to it, so that you can choose the right coverage for your vehicle.

It is noted that most people have no clear idea regarding comprehensive insurance vs. bumper-to-bumper insurance. So, here we will check the difference between these two types of coverage. 

Difference between bumper to bumper and comprehensive insurance

Comprehensive insurance covers a variety of risks, including the financial liabilities arising out of accidents caused to third parties by the insured vehicle and the financial loss due to damage to the car by natural or manmade calamities and theft of the vehicle. However, it only provides a part of the coverage because depreciation is considered when resolving vehicle damage claims. This means the compensation we would receive will be less considering the depreciation of motor parts. This is where bumper-to-bumper add-on comes to our rescue.

Bumper-to-bumper insurance, sometimes called zero depreciation or nil depreciation insurance, provides complete coverage for your car by paying out 100% of the claim value without considering the vehicle's depreciation.

Here is a comprehensive Vs bumper-to-bumper car insurance table for your easy understanding.

Parameters

Comprehensive insurance

Bumper-to-bumper insurance

Coverage

Considers depreciation of parts

Does not consider the depreciation of parts

Age of car

Up to 15 years

Up to 5 years

Type of car

All types

All types

Claims

No limit on claims

Unlimited claims available

Protection against theft

Available

Available

Airbags

Partial

Full

Compensation for components

Covers but depreciation rates applicable

Covers without considering depreciation

 

Comprehensive vs bumper to bumper - Which one to consider?

Those looking for comprehensive coverage for their car and stable finances in the event of damages or loss may consider comprehensive car insurance. This covers financial liabilities arising from third-party damages and damages to own car. However, when making a claim, the insurer will reduce the compensation amount, considering the depreciation of vehicle parts.

If you want a full claim amount without any deduction of the depreciation value from the coverage amount, consider a bumper-to-bumper add-on with your basic car insurance. Owners of luxury or premium cars would significantly benefit from this choice, as insurance offers complete protection against minor dents and expensive repairs.

Both types have advantages. Knowing the difference between bumper-to-bumper and comprehensive insurance is necessary to choose the best one for our car.

 


Disclaimer: The information provided in this blog is for educational and informational purposes only. It may contain outdated data and information regarding the topic featured in the article. It is advised to verify the currency and relevance of the data and information before taking any major steps. ICICI Lombard is not liable for any inaccuracies or consequences resulting from the use of this outdated information.

Also read:

  • Looking for tailored advice?

    Schedule a call with our insurance advisors

  • OR
  • Call us:

    1800 2666
Please enter valid name
Please enter a valid mobile number
Please select the Category

Subscribe to our newsletter

Understand insurance better by reading our helpful guides, articles, blogs and other information.

Please enter valid name
Please enter valid Email

Error message here